andallthat.co.uk
  • Blog
    • SubBlog
  • America 1789-1900
  • MeetTheHistorians
  • Contact

"Making Good Progress?" Final Thoughts: A useful summary but a missed opportunity

2/14/2017

1 Comment

 
Picture
Overt the last 2 weeks I have been reading and analysing Daisy Christodoulou's latest book "Making Good Progress?" This is an area which I have long been interested in, as followers on my blog will know.

You can find the chapter analyses below, however I want to offer something by way of an overall summary of the book.

CHAPTER 1 - Why didn't AfL Transform Schools?
CHAPTER 2 - Curriculum Aims and Teaching Methods
CHAPTER 3 - Making Valid Inferences
CHAPTER 4 - Descriptor Based Assessment
CHAPTER 5 - Exam Based Assessment
CHAPTER 6 - Life After Levels
CHAPTER 7 - Improving Formative Assessment
CHAPTER 8 - Improving Summative Assessment
CHAPTER 9 - An Integrated Assesment System

In Conclusion... 
I generally enjoyed reading “Making good progress?” and found the argument cogent and, on the surface, persuasive. I do however have some reservations about Christodoulou’s complete rejection of carefully considered constructivism, as I detail in the chapter reviews. If nothing else, Christodoulou has provided a useful synthesis of many decades of thought on assessment, across many disciplines. 
​
Yet I also feel like the book was something of a missed opportunity. If it is read widely, then this book may have a big impact (though I imagine it will circulate 
the usual group of people who engage in this sort of reading). However, in essence, the text does not add much to the body of knowledge already out there on assessment. Black and William cover almost all of these issues and there is a wide body of accessible research in fields such as cognitive science which is already available to teachers. Willingham is one good example of a researcher who produces very accessible papers. Indeed, many of these works are already a core part of most ITT programmes.

Limited progress in understanding the classroom view of progress
There is certainly a place for analyses of the state of play like this, but even then I am not sure it adds much to the overall picture. Where Christodoulou might have productively added to the debate might have been in a contribution to the empirical work on understanding schools' interpretations of assessment. There is huge scope for a proper investigation into teachers’ understanding of progression, something which might have been done via her connections with the Ark chain. Certainly, such a study might have illuminated more about why so many teachers have struggled to make progress in their understanding of progress.
 
On this theme, and with scant supporting evidence, I remain less than convinced by Christodoulou’s underlying suggestion that philosophical divisions explain the lack of effective assessment in schools, and the dominance of the “generic skills”. Christodoulou sees education as being driven by great, clashing ideologies: her science of cognition versus the religion of “generic skills”. Looking primarily at those in educational leadership (promoted via various government schemes), and the inevitable backlash against such leaders; the directions promoted by the inspection regime (historically); and the scrawlings of high profile agitators; certainly suggested an enormous ideological gulf. Yet I would argue that what we are seeing is nothing more than a coup at the very top level of education - one educational philosophy battling for supremacy with another.

To give an analogy, viewed from above, the English Reformation appears to be a seismic shift in people’s attitudes and beliefs brought about through a great battle of ideas. Yet, viewed from below, the Reformation can be seen as a much longer process of everyday conservatism and resistance, accompanied by more gradual acceptance and compromise.

Observed from the perspective of the classroom teacher, I suspect the picture is quite a different one to that painted by Christodoulou. Experience suggests that the majority of teachers already practice many of the approaches that Christodoulou is keen to promote, but probably use these alongside generic approaches as well. Most are governed by a general pragmatism: responding to pressure from senior leaders, but also having an awareness of what works in the privacy of their classroom. Some more detailed research into attitudes of classroom teachers would have allowed us to gain a greater insight into this crucial area.  Unless we understand the processes by which teachers understand assessment, we will never really be able to grasp how meaningful change can be brought about. As I have suggested before, shouting at people until they comply is not the same as shifting mindsets.

​Final Thoughts
Despite the reservations I have just outlined, the book (with notable oversights in terms of reliability and validity) is a useful introduction to the principles of assessment if read in context. It is certainly a good way to understand the politics of the current educational landscape and I will be recommending chapters 3, 6, 7 and 8 to my trainees.

My sincere hope however, is that we now see some meaningful research done on how classroom teachers have navigated this world of political interference in their classrooms and to gauge the needs we need to meet in the average classroom.

1 Comment
K
4/18/2020 11:37:50 am

I really liked this review. There is so much praise for this book and I was highly recommended it, but I was a little underwhelmed by it and somewhat confused by all of the hype surrounding it. I thought her explanations of why models fail were a little convenient, and it felt like she was structuring the book to carefully set up for her own policies, which will have their own issues, because there is just no one size fits all in teaching. I was also surprised when there was a revelation about using textbooks - textbooks are great if used well, and not so great if they are used poorly... as with everything in teaching.
The book reminded me of the quote "there is nothing new under the sun" and left me with the same conclusion as before - that effective education inevitably lies with good teaching, rather than with policy intricacies.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Image (c) LiamGM (2024) File: Bayeux Tapestry - Motte Castle Dinan.jpg - Wikimedia Commons

    Archives

    August 2024
    November 2022
    September 2022
    April 2022
    February 2022
    March 2021
    August 2020
    July 2020
    October 2019
    August 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    August 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    February 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    November 2013
    October 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    April 2013
    February 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    March 2011
    February 2011
    June 2000

    Categories

    All
    2014 KS3 Curriculum
    Book Review
    BUSK Reading
    Christmas
    Comment
    History Ancient
    History C19th
    History C20th
    History Early Modern
    History Medieval
    History Thematic
    Ofsted
    PGCE
    Rant
    Teachers Assessment
    Teachers Case Study
    Teachers Classroom Management
    Teachers Concepts
    Teachers Conference Notes
    Teachers Curriculum
    Teachers Exams
    Teachers Frideas
    Teachers Government
    Teachers Leadership
    Teachers Misc
    Teachers NQT
    Teachers Pedagogy
    Teachers Planning
    Teachers Progression
    Teachers Purpose
    Teachers Stand Alone Lessons
    Teachers Technology
    Teachers Training
    Teachers Trips
    Tvfilm Reviews79f7bb4075

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Blog
    • SubBlog
  • America 1789-1900
  • MeetTheHistorians
  • Contact